John Wayne Airport - home

 

ORANGE COUNTY AIRPORT COMMISSION
Eddie Martin Building
Airport Commission Hearing Room
3160 Airway Avenue
Costa Mesa, California 92626

MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING

October 15, 2008

 

COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:

Cheri Pham, Stephen Bristol, Stephen Blythe

   

COMMISSIONERS ABSENT:

Bruce Junor, Chris Welsh

   

STAFF PRESENT:

Alan Murphy, Airport Director
Richard Oviedo, Senior Deputy County Counsel
Larry Serafini, Deputy Airport Director, Facilities
Roy Freeman, Deputy Airport Director, Business Development
Ralph Sanchez, Administrative Manager, Business Development
David DeLeon, Administrative Manager, Business Development
Melissa Rice, Administrative Manager, Business Development
Barbara Swift, Real Property Agent, Business Development
Jeannette Grieco, Administrative Manager, Facilities
Elsa Garcia, Staff Specialist

   

INTERIM OFFICER ELECTION:

In the absence of the Chair and Vice Chair, Commissioner Bristol was temporarily appointed Chair on the nomination and second of Commissioners Pham and Blythe respectively.
   

CALL TO ORDER:

Commissioner Bristol called the meeting to order.

   

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:

Commissioner Blythe led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance.

   
  1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES. Regular Meeting Minutes of October 1, 2008. On the motion and second of Commissioner Bristol and Pham respectively, the minutes were unanimously approved as written.

  2. AWARD TAXICAB OPERATING AGREEMENT (ASR 08-001990). Airport Director requests Airport Commission concurrence with the Recommended Board Action to award a Taxicab Operating Agreement to John Wayne Airport Yellow Cab for taxicab service at John Wayne Airport. Director Murphy stated that a request for proposal process was used with seven (7) specific areas of criteria. A committee of seven (7) members was formed with five (5) airport personnel and two (2) non-personnel. The unanimous decision was to select John Wayne Airport Yellow Cab, with A White & Yellow Taxi as the second selection and American Ground Transportation as the third. William Gray of A White and Yellow Taxi in Santa Ana addressed the Commission to protest against the selection, stating that results were skewed and a negative slant was used in grading. Mr. Gray requested Commission consideration to review scoring, noting alternative fuel and fleet plans. Tim Conlon of John Wayne Airport Yellow Cab in Santa Ana addressed the Commission and stated that scoring reflected the proposals and made himself available for questions. Larry Slagle of John Wayne Airport Yellow Cab in Santa Ana stated his firm’s commitment to natural gas use. Responding to Commissioner Pham, Director Murphy stated that the issue of alternative fuels arose and an addenda was sent to all potential proposers to include the use of super ultra low emission vehicles (SULEV) if they so chose. In addition, Director Murphy stated that all committee members were in agreement with the ranking of firms with no great anomalies. Commissioner Bristol addressed Mr. Gray stating that the alternative fuel issue weighed as 10% of scoring and was insufficient to change overall rankings, to which Mr. Gray responded that this scoring section was just an example of bias against his firm. Responding to Commissioner Pham, Director Murphy confirmed that the committee considered John Wayne Airport Yellow Cab’s combined working capital with assets three (3) times greater than liabilities when scoring the financial viability section, a significant difference from the other two firms that showed little or no working capital. Commissioner Bristol expressed the importance of financial strength in the current marketplace.

    On Commissioner Blythe’s motion and Commissioner Pham’s second, Item 2 unanimously passed.

  3. ADOPT LIST OF PREQUALIFIED CONTRACTORS FOR PARKING STRUCTURE C (ASR 08-002099). Airport Director requests Airport Commission concurrence with the Recommended Board Action to adopt the list of prequalified general contractors and subcontractors to bid on the Parking Structure C project. Director Murphy explained that eleven (11) prequalification packages were received and qualified, for a competitive bid process.

    On Commissioner Pham’s motion and Commissioner Blythe’s second, Item 3 unanimously passed.

  4. SUMMARY OF RELEVANT ACTIONS – Items were approved as recommended.

  5. ADDITIONAL BUSINESS

    1. Other Business - None.

    2. Legislative Update - None.

    3. Update on Airport Improvement Project – Construction progress presentation by Deputy Director Serafini.

  6. ITEMS OF INTEREST TO THE PUBLIC – None.

  7. ADJOURNMENT OF PUBLIC MEETING. Having no further business to conduct, the meeting adjourned at 5:35 p.m.

Respectfully submitted,


Elsa Garcia
Staff Specialist